Error message

Warning: preg_match(): Allocation of JIT memory failed, PCRE JIT will be disabled. This is likely caused by security restrictions. Either grant PHP permission to allocate executable memory, or set pcre.jit=0 in drupal_valid_http_host() (line 743 of includes/bootstrap.inc).

Article/Publication Details

Lewisian-Style Counterfactual Analysis of Causation: A New Solution to the Overdetermination Problem

(Original title: Lewisian-Style Counterfactual Analysis of Causation: A New Solution to the Overdetermination Problem)
Organon F, 2010, vol. 17, No 4, pp. 461-476.
File to download: PDF*
BibTex EndNote Tagged EndNote XML RIS

Document Statistics:

Number of visits: 3,681
Number of visits today: 2
Last visit: 19.11.2026 - 18:20
PDF downloads: 1007

Abstract

Causal overdetermination – i.e. instances in which x, y, and z all occur and intuitively the occurrence of x alone is sufficient for the occurrence of z and the occurrence of y alone is sufficient for the occurrence of z – has long been considered a problem for counterfactual analyses of causation. Intuitively, we want to say both x and y caused z, but standard Lewisian counterfactual analysis yields the result that neither x nor y caused z. David Lewis, himself, suggested that overdetermination ought to be left as “spoils to the victor”. I show how, if we modify Lewis’ account of events slightly, we can bring counterfactual analysis in line with our intuitions about overdetermination.

*The article is subject to copyright.